Officers 'breached right to silence' in botched arrest

The actions of three NSW Police officers have been criticised by a judge and a watchdog. (Dean Lewins/AAP PHOTOS)

Police officers lacked common sense and basic respect for fairness by continuing to interview an Indigenous man trying to exercise a right to silence, a watchdog says.

The three officers face possible demotion after their arrest and questioning of the 29-year-old with intellectual limitations was criticised by a NSW judge, public prosecutors and the state's police watchdog.

Despite being told by the man's lawyer that he did not want to be questioned, police interviewed him twice - including after he indicated five times that he wanted to stop to seek legal advice.

One constable was also found to have recklessly put false information to the suspect.

Another officer "did less than the bare minimum" in his role as the police station's custody manager, having been told by a lawyer the suspect did not want to be interviewed, the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission said.

NSW Police logo
One constable was found to have recklessly put false information to a suspect.

The man admitted to several matters including things he could not have been involved in, the watchdog said.

Subsequent charges were tossed out two years later by a judge due to the pressure placed on the man.

The watchdog's report on the case follows its December 2023 finding that NSW Police Force had a systemic problem of officers interviewing vulnerable people after they had received legal advice and said they did not wish to be interviewed.

In some instances, pressure and a perceived obligation to make a prosecution stick meant officers pushed a case in any way that allowed a charge to be laid, a criminal lawyer said.

"It's the hope that they will get away with it," Redfern Legal Centre supervising solicitor Samantha Lee told AAP.

"It not only has terrible impacts for the person in the police station being questioned but also as in this recent case, police are risking the whole criminal process.

"You've got the Miami Vice coming through in Sydney police."

She also highlighted what she described as tension between a custody manager's desire to be part of the police team and their obligation to ensure arrested people's rights are adhered to.

"What's showing up in these cases is there is a huge conflict of interest," Ms Lee said.

The charges were tossed out in 2022 when a judge found the man had clearly exercised his right to silence.

"Contravention of the accused’s right to silence, particularly as a vulnerable person and in the absence of a support person, is very grave," Judge Siobhan Herbert said.

Public prosecutors then referred the matter to the police watchdog.

The commission, which made serious misconduct findings against all three officers, rejected claims by one officer that systemic issues mitigated his conduct.

"The inability of an officer to respect such a basic request cannot be blamed on any other factor," the commission said in a report.

"Regardless of systemic issues, any officer with common sense and basic respect for fairness would have complied with (the suspect's) request to stop the interview for legal advice."

The watchdog recommended disciplinary action such as reducing the officers' rank but not dismissal.

The force said it was considering the recommendations and noted changes since the 2020 incident.

"This includes instructions issued to officers in December 2023 regarding the process to follow when a person declines to be interviewed," a police spokeswoman said.

License this article

What is AAPNews?

For the first time, Australian Associated Press is delivering news straight to the consumer.

No ads. No spin. News straight-up.

Not only do you get to enjoy high-quality news delivered straight to your desktop or device, you do so in the knowledge you are supporting media diversity in Australia.

AAP Is Australia’s only independent newswire service, free from political and commercial influence, producing fact-based public interest journalism across a range of topics including politics, courts, sport, finance and entertainment.

What is AAPNews?
The Morning Wire

Wake up to AAPNews’ morning news bulletin delivered straight to your inbox or mobile device, bringing you up to speed with all that has happened overnight at home and abroad, as well as setting you up what the day has in store.

AAPNews Morning Wire
AAPNews Breaking News
Breaking News

Be the first to know when major breaking news happens.


Notifications will be sent to your device whenever a big story breaks, ensuring you are never in the dark when the talking points happen.

Focused Content

Enjoy the best of AAP’s specialised Topics in Focus. AAP has reporters dedicated to bringing you hard news and feature content across a range of specialised topics including Environment, Agriculture, Future Economies, Arts and Refugee Issues.

AAPNews Focussed Content
Subscription Plans

Choose the plan that best fits your needs. AAPNews offers two basic subscriptions, all billed monthly.

Once you sign up, you will have seven days to test out the service before being billed.

AAPNews Full Access Plan
Full Access
AU$10
  • Enjoy all that AAPNews has to offer
  • Access to breaking news notifications and bulletins
  • Includes access to all AAPNews’ specialised topics
Join Now
AAPNews Student Access Plan
Student Access
AU$5
  • Gain access via a verified student email account
  • Enjoy all the benefits of the ‘Full Access’ plan at a reduced rate
  • Subscription renews each month
Join Now
AAPNews Annual Access Plan
Annual Access
AU$99
  • All the benefits of the 'Full Access' subscription at a discounted rate
  • Subscription automatically renews after 12 months
Join Now

AAPNews also offers enterprise deals for businesses so you can provide an AAPNews account for your team, organisation or customers. Click here to contact AAP to sign-up your business today.

SEVEN DAYS FREE
Download the app
Download AAPNews on the App StoreDownload AAPNews on the Google Play Store