Return of tower residents not 'mathematically possible'

It is not "mathematically possible" for some residents of Victoria's public housing towers to return after they are knocked down and rebuilt, a court has heard.

A hearing for a class action against the state government over its plan to demolish and rebuild all 44 of Melbourne's high-rise public housing towers was held in Victoria's Supreme Court on Tuesday.

The public housing towers are set to be redeveloped by 2051, with five in Flemington, North Melbourne and Carlton to be replaced by 2031.

The project was a key pillar of the state government's housing statement, unveiled by then premier Daniel Andrews in September, and will lead to the forcible relocation of more than 10,000 residents.

Alfred Street public housing tower during lockdown (file image)
The lead plaintiff from a North Melbourne tower was in a class action over its COVID lockdown.

Some claim their human rights were not properly considered and want the plan to be paused and reconsidered.

The case's lead plaintiff is Barry Berih, a tenant of a tower on Alfred Street in North Melbourne who was previously involved in a class action against the state government over its sudden COVID lockdown of tower residents in 2020.

His barrister Leigh Howard said there was no evidence of cabinet considering residents' human rights before announcing the plan, which the government says will boost social housing by 10 per cent across the sites.

"They found out by the news," he said.

Some 427 of the 484 residents who would be captured in the class action have already signed relocation agreements.

But Mr Howard said there was separate pledge given to pre-existing tenants on Abbotsford Street in North Melbourne, signed by former minister Martin Foley, guaranteeing the right to return to their estate after construction is finished.

"It's not mathematically possible to, like-for-like, relocate these tenants," Mr Howard said.

"The evidence of the Abbotsford Street development has been completely misrepresented."

Mr Howard pushed for an injunction on the government signing contracts to redevelop the towers.

A demolition tender is set to be released in April but defence counsel Liam Brown SC said no contract would be awarded until the third quarter of this year.

He raised an estimate from Homes Victoria chief executive Simon Newport that an injunction, if granted, would cost the agency $130,000 a month to hold nearby properties for residents to move into.

Justice Andrew Keogh said an early trial would negate the need to "kick the can down the road" but flagged he would consider requiring the defendant to give 14 days' notice.

Homes Victoria estimates renovating and maintaining the 44 towers instead of rebuilding would cost $2.3 billion over 20 years, or about $55 million per tower.

Mr Brown argued cabinet acted within its remit as the government's "supreme policymaking body" and flagged it would move for summary dismissal of the case.

"What we say, when one has regard to the entirety of the housing statement, is that this is a quintessential policy decision," he said.

"It's a decision about how the state should facilitate access to housing in this state."

Justice Keogh suggested the case would likely proceed to trial across two days in July if the summary dismissal application was knocked back.

Premier Jacinta Allan said the redevelopment plans would take advantage of the sites' proximity to jobs and public transport.

"This is exactly the sort of place we want to build more homes," she told reporters.

What is AAPNews?

For the first time, Australian Associated Press is delivering news straight to the consumer.

No ads. No spin. News straight-up.

Not only do you get to enjoy high-quality news delivered straight to your desktop or device, you do so in the knowledge you are supporting media diversity in Australia.

AAP Is Australia’s only independent newswire service, free from political and commercial influence, producing fact-based public interest journalism across a range of topics including politics, courts, sport, finance and entertainment.

What is AAPNews?
The Morning Wire

Wake up to AAPNews’ morning news bulletin delivered straight to your inbox or mobile device, bringing you up to speed with all that has happened overnight at home and abroad, as well as setting you up what the day has in store.

AAPNews Morning Wire
AAPNews Breaking News
Breaking News

Be the first to know when major breaking news happens.


Notifications will be sent to your device whenever a big story breaks, ensuring you are never in the dark when the talking points happen.

Focused Content

Enjoy the best of AAP’s specialised Topics in Focus. AAP has reporters dedicated to bringing you hard news and feature content across a range of specialised topics including Environment, Agriculture, Future Economies, Arts and Refugee Issues.

AAPNews Focussed Content
Subscription Plans

Choose the plan that best fits your needs. AAPNews offers two basic subscriptions, all billed monthly.

Once you sign up, you will have seven days to test out the service before being billed.

AAPNews Full Access Plan
Full Access
AU$10
  • Enjoy all that AAPNews has to offer
  • Access to breaking news notifications and bulletins
  • Includes access to all AAPNews’ specialised topics
Join Now
AAPNews Student Access Plan
Student Access
AU$5
  • Gain access via a verified student email account
  • Enjoy all the benefits of the ‘Full Access’ plan at a reduced rate
  • Subscription renews each month
Join Now
AAPNews Annual Access Plan
Annual Access
AU$99
  • All the benefits of the 'Full Access' subscription at a discounted rate
  • Subscription automatically renews after 12 months
Join Now

AAPNews also offers enterprise deals for businesses so you can provide an AAPNews account for your team, organisation or customers. Click here to contact AAP to sign-up your business today.

SEVEN DAYS FREE
Download the app
Download AAPNews on the App StoreDownload AAPNews on the Google Play Store